You Are Viewing

A Blog Post

Cheryl Dumesnil, “When Lesbo Mom Reads to the First Graders”

Never missing a teachable moment, more about Supermom, Supergay, and Superwriter  Cheryl Dumesnil contributed this article to Out & Around. We love her as our California correspondent writing about the crossroads of parenthood, lesbians and suburbia.

The Queerest Book on the Shelf or When Lesbo Mom Reads to the First Graders

My kids’ bookcase is full of banned books: Heather has Two Mommies, 10,000 Dresses, And Tango Makes Three, The Boy Who Cried Fabulous, to name a few. However, when the principal of my oldest son’s elementary school asked me to volunteer as a guest reader on “Read Across America Day,” I didn’t even consider reading one of these. Not because I’m some big-chicken-scaredy-cat. No, I’m not adverse to rustling up some controversial grub in the service of a larger ideal like queer visibility. In fact, each year I gift my sons’ teachers with at least one of these titles, to make sure my kiddos have books in class that reflect their family and community. But it wasn’t the Queer Activist in me who chose to read Miss Twiggley’s Tree by Dorothea Warren Fox to my son’s first grade class; it was the Mom and Educator in me.

The Mom in me picked dear ol’ Miss Twiggley because it was my one of my favorite books when I was a kid. In fact, my own mom read that book so many times that my whole family could recite its rhyming lines. The Educator in me picked the story because it’s full of Important Lessons about Bravery, Generosity, and Accepting Our Differences. The Queer Activist? Well, she was down with the choice because she knows Twiggley is one of the queerest dames in town.

Check it out:

Funny Miss Twiggley
Lived in a tree
With a dog named Puss
[ed. note: Seriously?]
And a color TV.

It gets better:

She named her dog Puss—
He didn’t mind that.
“My very best friend,”
He said, “is a cat.”
[ed. note: Uh huh.]

And the kicker:

Old Miss Twiggley
Was friendly with bears.
[ed. note: Yes, it really says Bears.]
“They shed on the sofa,” she said,
“but who cares!
They don’t find me odd
And I’m grateful for that.
I don’t think they’d mind
If I slept in my hat.”
And just to be sure . . .
she slept in her hat.
[ed. note: Go Twiggley.]

Okay, So Miss T’s lifestyle is a little unusual. And the townspeople totally have their Underoos in a twist about that. The town dogs bully poor Puss whenever he goes grocery shopping. Miss T, well, she hides out in the tree all day. And why wouldn’t she? She’s got “the mayor’s wife” talking smack about her to anyone who will listen, calling our dear Miss T “disgraceful” and “a nuisance,” insisting, “My husband must know / Of a town law,” said she. / “Against things of that kind / Going on in a tree.”

Really? “Town law”? “Things of that kind”? Come on. How queer can this story get?

But, all “reading through a rainbow lens” aside, the truly subversive beauty of this book is that it doesn’t establish a recognizable identity category that makes Miss Twiggley the town oddball. She’s not the wrong race; she’s not wrongly gendered; she’s not the wrong sexual orientation, religion, or political party. She’s just quirky. Which means anyone can relate to her, because we’re all quirky, right? She’s not an “other.” She’s not a “them.” She’s an “all of us.”

See, that’s the shortcoming of identity politics: it always breaks down into “our group” versus “their group.” The discourse disintegrates into cranky six-year-olds (or sixty-six-year-olds, as the case may be) screaming at each other, in that did-not/did-too/did-not/did-too way, which devolves into the fingers-in-ears-la-la-la-la-I’m-not-listening-to-you thing, which ultimately gets us nowhere we want to be.

Take for instance Rush Limbaugh’s recent media-attention-getting move. Okay, he makes a trademark nasty comment. (Big surprise.) Next day, my Facebook page has broken out in a Repeal Rush Rash—friends posting petitions to sign, boycotts to join. So, yes, right on! Eliminate hatemongering! Except guess how my FB friends are introducing these Shush Rush opportunities? “Let’s kick this asshole off the airwaves!” Hmmm. Remember Audre Lorde’s essay, “The Master’s Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master’s House”? Or that whole eye-for-an-eye business? No matter how closely Rush might resemble an orifice that spews diarrhea, in our response to him, could we use language that doesn’t also stink like a steaming pile of hatred? You know, higher road, and all that?

Anyway, back to the righteous Miss T. Guess what happens? Well, the whole town floods (in a sing-song rhythm that’s not at all scary to kids), washing out every home, except the one in the tree. And what does our heroine do? She puts Puss and her crew of Bears to work, expanding the tree house so all the townsfolk can live with her (until, presumably, FEMA helps them rebuild, in like, fifteen years). And yes, the Twigster’s new tenants include the mayor’s wife, who sleeps “safe and sound” in Miss Twiggley’s bed, wearing Miss Twiggley’s hat. [ed. note: Mm hmmmm.]

Now, I realize I could have chosen a book about a kid who has two moms, and maybe that would have helped my own little guy feel better represented in his class. But I chose a book about difference in general, and I’d like to think maybe that helped not just my guy, but, say, the kid in the back row who wants to share his encyclopedic knowledge of ocean predators, all day; or the six-year-old stomach cancer survivor, whose short crop of feather-fuzzy hair is a testament to her chemo days; or the first-generation U.S.-born children whose families honor cultural traditions the Anglo kids are learning about for the first time; or the kids who don’t know what to do when someone else’s differences make them uncomfortable.

Which begs the question: What can we do when we feel uncomfortable in the face of our differences? Well, according to Miss Twiggley and the ragtag crew of first graders I was hanging with yesterday, instead of being scared and mean, we can be curious and brave.

Sounds like a good start to me.



Miss Twiggley’s Tree, copyright 1966, by Dorothea Warren Fox, Purple House Press.

Leave a Reply

WordPress Video Lightbox